Our History

Elmer Harris

Prince Edward Island is the traditional and unceded territory of several Mi’kmaq First Nations. The Mi’kmaq people have lived on PEI for thousands of years.

Our province’s population also includes many other Indigenous peoples, such as Metis and Inuit, who have made PEI their home. Many people do not know the rich history and traditions of Indigenous peoples. Elders, ceremony, and family are the core of Indigenous cultures.

Our beautiful property was built in 1913 as the summer home for Broadway playwright Elmer Harris and family. In those days Fortune was an artists’ colony made up of Broadway and silent screen actors escaping the New York City summer heat. In later years, our Inn had other famous theatrical owners. Actress Colleen Dewhurst, famously known for her role as Marilla Cuthburt in Anne of Green Gables and her husband, Hollywood actor George C. Scott spent many summers enjoying the bounties and sights of this fair isle. In 1989 the Wilmer family took on a labour of love, transforming our unique property into a country inn.

The Inn

In 1991 our Chef Proprietor, Michael Smith turned our Inn’s restaurant into one of Prince Edward Island’s most important culinary destinations, pushing the boundaries of local cuisine. Seven years later in 1998 the Inn had gained so much notoriety that a new kitchen, dining room and guest wing were added. 2015 marked the return of Chef Michael, this time with his wife Chastity as InnKeeper and Chief Designer of the property. In 2016 The Inn at Bay Fortune received its 5-star rating, making it the only 5-star country inn on Prince Edward Island.

Registration

Forgotten Password?